Monday, March 3, 2025

NetGalley Review Grab Bag Volume 7

 And we are back with more reviews! I have a very serious post in the works right now that will hopefully be out some time this month but in the meantime, let's check in on some new releases. 

I received free advance copies from NetGalley in exchange for a fair review.


Title: Hauntress

Author/Illustrator: Minetarō Mochizuki

Rating: 2/5

Published by Kodansha and available February 25, 2025, Hauntress is a major work in the horror genre for manga. It was published in 1993, before stalking was widely known in Japan. The story follows college student Hiroshi, who's being followed by a creepy woman. I was interested because it's on several "Scariest Manga Ever" lists and I do love a good scare. Unfortunately it's hard to make a drawing scary and this isn't scary to me. The stalking starts too early with no buildup, which ruins the tension. I did like that at the end the stalker becomes another urban legend (Japan is famous for its urban legends). The art reminds me of Junji Ito, which I know for other readers will be a plus but the one Ito book I've read didn't impress me much. This just wasn't scary for me.

---

Title: Once Was Willem 

Author: M. R. Carey

Rating: 4/5

Published by Orbit Books and available March 4, 2025, Once Was Willem is something I thought I'd never find a good example of -- a fantasy story set in a real medieval era. This story follows a revenant (a reanimated corpse) and his found family of shape-shifters and spirits as they fight to defend the town's children from an evil sorcerer. The book combines dark fantasy, medieval folklore, and Gnosticism for the worldbuilding, and I was really impressed. I'm not particularly a fantasy fan and I've read too many bad attempts to mix fantasy with the Middle Ages but this was not one of them. There was a major historical error, referencing the so-called Children's Crusade before it was said to have happened, but that was all I caught, and for the most part the historical detail is really nice. This will appeal to fans of both dark fantasy and realistic depictions of the Middle Ages, as well as those of you who are monster lovers (hey, I'm one too!)

---


Title: 
Dogsred Vol. 1

Author: Satoru Noda

Rating: 4/5

Published by Viz Media and available March 18, 2025, Dogsred Vol. 1 is the first volume of a new series by the author of Golden Kamuy. This series follows Rou, an ice skater looking for a second chance playing hockey. So yes, it is a sports manga. If that makes you think it's a story only for sports fans, you must never have read a sports manga. These are more often than not actually really exciting and full of emotion. Dogsred looks like it'll be no exception. The art is fantastic and conveys the speed and action of skating and I was immediately invested in Rou's story as he comes off tragedy and a breakdown to try to rebuild his life. I've never skated on ice but now I want to try it. This series will appeal to fans of action manga and stories about redemption, and maybe even the readers of all those hockey romances (assuming they actually like hockey).

---

Title: Kai and the Kappas

Author: Stefanie Gamarra

Illustrator: Marta Pilosio

Rating: 4/5

Self-published and available March 20, 2025, Kai and the Kappas is a picture book about a monster-loving boy in a retelling of the folktale of The Boy Who Cried Wolf (Perry Index # 210) It's very cute and will appeal to monster kids. The art is nice and looks almost like paper cutouts. I did think some of the text passages where a bit long, which depending on the age of the reader might lose them a bit, but that was just a few pages. This is a good retelling of a familiar fable and I like that it uses a non-Western creature, in this case a Japanese Yōkai. I'll definitely suggest it to our picture book selector.


---


Title:
Viral Hit Vol. 1

Author: Taejun Pak

Illustrator: Kim Junghyun

Rating: 2.5

Published by Wattpad WEBTOON Book Group and available April 1, 2025, Viral Hit is a Korean webtoon now being published physically. I can't seem to get into webtoons/manwa but I look into them for work and these reviews. This series follows a bullied high schooler as he goes viral for fighting bullies on stream. The art is pretty good -- manwa tends to have pretty impressive realistic art and this is no exception. The premise will appeal to people interested in streaming culture and heroes starting from zero, but it just didn't interest me. The constant profanity, which is censored with asterisks, feels like they're trying too hard to be edgy and just looks dumb. It was funny seeing a kimchi slap right out of a K-drama (like this iconic video) though.

---

Title: Men of the Harem Vol. 1

Authors: Alphatart (original story), Herelee (adaptor)

Illustrator: Yeongbin

Rating: 3/5

Published by Yen Press and available December 10, 2024, Men of the Harem Vol. 1 is already out but is still up on NetGalley and I requested it not noticing the release date. Oh well. Men of the Harem is another webtoon but I was more interested in this than Viral Hit. It follows a female emperor as she solidifies her power and plans to break with tradition and gender norms and gather a male harem for herself. I enjoy polyamory and gender subversion in fiction so I was interested. The art is very nice and I think the premise will be fun to see play out in future volumes. It takes place in a fantasy world, so silly names are all over the place. Despite her weird name, I do like the main character, Latrasil, and I can't wait to see her with her harem of pretty boys.

---


Title:
 Semantic Error Vol. 1

Author: J. Soori

Illustrator: Angy

Rating: 4/5

Published by Yen Press and available November 19, 2024, Semantic Error is another book still on NetGalley that I failed to see the publishing date of. It's also another webtoon/manwa. This time it's a boy's love series, centered around two college students, one who has it out for the other after his graduation plan is ruined. So yes, it's one of those enemies-to-lovers stories that are all the rage lately. The art isn't as good as I've seen in other manwa (one of the main characters consistently has a huge body, making his head out of proportionally small). I've had little success with finding a manwa that interests me, but I think I like this one. The characters actually feel fleshed out and the plot is engaging. I can see why this is considered one of the best Korean BL.

Friday, January 17, 2025

NetGalley Review Grab Bag Volume 6 - New Year, New Books

 Happy belated New Year everyone! Today is our first batch of NetGalley reviews. We have several to get through so let's just get into it.

I received free review copies from the publishers and NetGalley in exchange for a fair review.

Title: Dogs and Punching Bags

Author/Illustrator: Kaori Ozaki

Rating: 4/5

Published by Kodansha and available January 21, 2025, Dogs and Punching Bags is a seinen manga following a woman's return to her small town home after heartbreak and her growing relationship with a strange young man with a tragic past. The rural setting is charming and captures the small town life where everyone knows everyone -- for better or for worse -- and the romance between the two leads is well done. This standalone volume will appeal to fans of rural settings, dramatic slice of life storytelling, as well as complex relationships and hopeful endings.


---

Title: Fall in Love, You False Angels, Vol. 1

Author/Illustrator: Coco Uzuki

Rating: 3/5

Published by Kodansha and available February 11, 2025, Fall In Love, You False Angels is a shojo high school romance. I was interested because the summary likened it to Kaguya-sama: Love Is War, which I do like. This series follows two perfect model students who both have secret, darker sides. I don't think this part is very well represented, all they do with their other sides is be more assertive (while still being good) and I may be missing some cultural context but I just think that part of the story is rather underdeveloped. The art is really nice and the characters overall are cute and likeable, so maybe time will bring out more of their characterization. This is, after all, just the first volume.


---
Title: Medieval Cats: Claws, Paws, and Kitties of Yore

Author: Catherine Nappington

Rating: 2/5

Published by Clarkson Potter/Ten Speed Press and available March 4, 2025, Medieval Cats immediately caught my eye as a medievalist and cat lover. And I really wanted to like this book, but several things hold it back. First and most egregious is its disregard for what the Middle Ages actually is. While the book itself places the Middle Ages between 500 and 1500 CE, which is a good estimate a lot of people use, it then ignores that and includes references to Shakespeare and even Isaac Newton, neither of whom were medieval. The images are properly cited fortunately, but there are no endnotes or other citations (at least in the ARC). I also couldn't find anything about the author (whose name I suspect is a pseudonym) and that bugs me. Overall it's got some good information about cats in the medieval period, but it's also unfocused and falls into the usual "Medieval means anything before the Industrial Revolution" folly so many non-academic things do.

---
Title: I Want To Love You Till Your Dying Day, Vol. 1

Author/Illustrator: Nachi Aono

Rating: 2/5

Published by Kodansha and available February 18, 2025, I Want to Love You Till Your Dying Day is a yuri (girl's love) manga with an interesting premise -- a boarding school that trains magical girls for combat. It made me think of a bit of the controversial Elfin Lied, which was also of the Cute Girls Being Killing Machines genre. This series is just getting its start in English and this is the first volume but I wasn't particularly impressed. The worldbuilding leaves a lot to be desired (what are they fighting and why?) and the bits of the magic system that are explained are dubious at best. The big act of magic shown is transferring mana via kissing, which since this is a yuri manga is of course an excuse for girls to kiss, which wouldn't be an issue if one of the main characters wasn't said to be ten years old. This is on top of a trans or gender non-conforming character being called a "pervert teacher" multiple times, a stereotype that needs to end. Needless to say I'm not impressed, though the character design is cute.

---

Title: Mujina Into the Deep, Vol. 1

Author/Illustrator: Inio Asano

Rating: 3/5

Published by Viz Media and available February 18, 2025, Mujina Into the Deep is the latest series from acclaimed mangaka Inio Asano, author of Goodbye Punpun. The summary caught my attention -- "In the near future, human rights aren't guarenteed, but they are for sale," especially since currently in my home country of the US human rights are very much up for debate. In this world, rights come with strict government control and people living outside these rights and control are called "mujina" (Japanese for badger). It is an interesting setup and I wonder how the story will develop for the main mujina, Ubume. I will say the constant sex is a little gratuitous and distracting, but the action is cool. It's rated M by Viz for some very good reasons. Because of how explicit it is I probably won't order it for my public library, but I am curious as to how it will turn out so I'll probably continue reading myself.

---

Title: RuriDragon, Vol. 1

Author: Masaoki Shindo

Rating: 5/5

Published by Viz Media and available January 7, 2025, RuriDragon is a shonen series I've been super excited for ever since I read the first chapter on Shuesha's Manga Plus app. Almost as soon as I started reading I was telling our teen manga selector that they need to get it for the collection. The premise is simple. Ruri Aoki wakes up one morning to find horns growing out of her head, and her mother reveals nonchalantly that the girl's absent father is a dragon. Ruri is an adorable character and her struggles with her new life are relatable to readers her age, half-dragon or not, like changing bodies and trying to fit in with peers. I think teen readers will really like this one. The art is cute and the story is just a nice slice of life thing about learning to live with unexpected developments in your life, a well as opening up to support from others-- because your friends really do want to help you.